[pmwiki-users] Discussion link / talk link help

[Ian MacGregor]

On Tuesday 24 July 2007 8:28:04 am H. Fox wrote:
> On 7/23/07, Ian MacGregor <lists at imacgregor.com> wrote:
> > This works great, thanks to Hagan for writing it up. My question is how
> > can I get all $group.$name-Talk pages to go into a dedicated group (let's
> > say the "Comments" group or "Talk" group) instead of the same group the
> > original page is in?
>
> Some questions:
>
> 1) What's the advantage of having comments in a different group?
>
> 2) How would PmWiki know what group a particular page resides in?  Put
> another way, if there's a Talk.SomePage discussion page, how would
> PmWiki know in which group contains the SomePage page?
>
> 3) What if there are two groups that have a page with the same name?
> How can there be discussion pages for both GroupOne.SomePage and
> GroupTwo.SomePage?
>
> One answer might be to do Talk.{$Group}-{$Name}, but then how do you
> resolve the difference between e.g. Bork-Bork.Bork and
> Bork.Bork-Bork's talk pages?
I would like all discussions to go into a dedicated group due to being more 
manageable for me (the administrator). If that's not possible, I simply won't 
use discussions.

Thanks,
Ian MacGregor

>
> Hagan

-- 
http://www.imacgregor.com
MacGregor Despite Them!